Mobile: 18688976300 (Mr. Peng) 15222276387 (Mr. Bai)
Email: pengwl@honred.com
QQ: 176496342
Address:Building A1, Runteng Industrial Park, Shiyan Street, Bao'an District, Shenzhen
A peak torque reading taken while removing a screw means little on its own. It is shaped simultaneously by thread condition, adhesive, plating, temperature and removal speed. Divided by the tightening torque originally applied at the same location, however, it becomes a stable indicator of the state of that threaded joint. No extra hardware is needed — one more recorded number in the removal program separates a batch of apparently normal screws into three classes.
The ratio is the breakaway peak torque at the moment of removal divided by the original tightening torque at the same joint. For dry, uncoated steel micro screws from M1.2 to M2.0, the empirical band is roughly seventy to ninety percent. Breakaway is lower than tightening because preload relaxes in service and because friction during loosening is usually lower than friction during rundown. Below seventy percent, preload has clearly decayed; above ninety percent, the joint probably never relaxed or something adds resistance. This band is not a standard. It must be calibrated per product, per plating system and per torque window; borrowing another product's numbers produces wrong conclusions.
A ratio above one hundred points first to threadlocker. A cured medium-strength adhesive lifts breakaway torque to one point one to one point five times the tightening value — intended behaviour, not a defect. The real concern is a high ratio at an unglued location, and there are three common causes. Plating friction drift, such as batch variation in zinc-nickel, raises actual friction above the design assumption in both directions. Thread interference or flank damage means local yielding already occurred during assembly, so extra torque is needed to break it free. Foreign matter or cured adhesive residue in the hole adds parasitic drag. The way to separate them is the distribution within a batch: adhesive-driven highs are tight and stable, damage-driven highs are scattered and come with abnormal torque-angle curves. On small screw removal equipment, logging breakaway and tightening as a pair is the cheapest way to catch this.
Below sixty percent, the joint can no longer be trusted to hold, even if it looks intact. There are three decay paths: creep in plastic or aluminium bosses, dropping preload over weeks; material relaxation under thermal cycling, especially near power devices; and tightening that was never on target to begin with, masked by later steps. The third is the most insidious — first article passes, sampling passes, but a drift window goes unrecorded until the screw is removed. At these locations the ratio is more diagnostic than raw torque, because it separates "never tightened enough" from "tightened, then loosened": the former shows a normal ratio with low absolute torque, the latter shows both low. An automatic vision screw removal machine that inspects head condition before removal screens out stripped and broken heads early, keeping them from polluting the sample.
For the ratio to be comparable, measurement conditions must converge. Three basics. The removal spindle must be coaxial with the thread axis; misalignment adds lateral friction and inflates the peak. Removal speed must match the calibration speed, since higher speed raises breakaway by more than ten percentage points. Workpiece temperature must be recorded, because cold and warm readings cannot be pooled. Peak capture also needs enough sampling rate: the breakaway peak of a micro screw often lasts around ten milliseconds, and slow sampling flattens it into falsely low data. When these conditions are not met the ratio still supports comparison within one batch, but not across batches or machines.
Making the ratio operational requires four hard-coded lines. A calibration line defines the reference band per joint and the sample size behind it. An alarm line triggers review rather than automatic rejection when the band is exceeded. A disposition line defines what happens to an alarmed part — reassembly verification, replacement, or full-unit repair. A data line defines how the ratio accumulates with removal cycles and after which cycle screws or threads must be replaced. Together with torque limits, these form a complete removal criterion: the ratio carries trend and state, absolute torque carries whether this particular removal may proceed. Built into the M0.8-M2.0 screw removal solution, the operator no longer sees isolated torque numbers but a state label for each location.
One caveat: the method assumes the same location, same size and same tightening setpoint. In mixed-model production sharing one station, statistics must be grouped by model, otherwise the distribution flattens and the alarm line stops working. In practice this trips up more projects than measurement accuracy does.
Related Articles
/ RECOMMENDED NEWS