Mobile: 18688976300 (Mr. Peng) 15222276387 (Mr. Bai)
Email: pengwl@honred.com
QQ: 176496342
Address:Building A1, Runteng Industrial Park, Shiyan Street, Bao'an District, Shenzhen
The most common error in repair quotations is pricing by the unit. Disassembly time on a single machine swings wildly at small sample sizes, and two of any ten units of the same model may take three times as long because a thread stripped, so a unit-averaged price both hides the problem and gives away the margin. Move the unit of account down to the individual screw and the cost structure becomes visible: which screw families are eating the profit, and which operation is generating rework, both become countable. The model is not complicated, but it needs four accounts present at once, and missing one produces the wrong answer.
Conclusion: cost per screw removed is the sum of direct labour, consumable amortisation, secondary damage loss and equipment amortisation, and secondary damage is the one most often left out. Direct labour is standard time multiplied by labour rate, and standard time should be weighted by screw count rather than total machine time divided by total screws, because difficulty varies widely by position and an M1.2 on a control board is not in the same class as an M2.0 on a shell. Consumables amortise on bit life: one bit may last a few hundred cycles in small plastic screws and several thousand in metal, which puts the per-screw bit cost an order of magnitude apart. Equipment amortises over depreciation life and actual utilisation, and low utilisation inflates the per-screw share. Secondary damage loss is repair cost multiplied by incidence, an item that almost never appears in a quotation and is the main source of loss in repair work.
Conclusion: secondary damage should be costed by the repair action it triggers rather than by the purchase price of the damaged part, and the two are often three to ten times apart. A stripped M1.4 screw has negligible part value, yet the actions it triggers include extracting the remnant, cleaning swarf from the bore, deciding whether a brass insert is needed, replacing the shell or reinforcing the structure if the bore has cracked, and re-inspection afterwards. That work usually runs five to twenty times a normal removal, depends heavily on technician skill, and cannot be scheduled to a standard. Worse, it clusters: when a batch of incoming units shares a condition, secondary damage arrives in a lump and drags the month's yield down at once. In the model it should be estimated as incidence times average repair hours times labour rate, with incidence split by incoming condition, because new units, owner-opened units and outdoor-service units must be counted separately or the average will mask the real risk.
Conclusion: in high-mix low-volume work, changeover time affects cost per screw more than the price difference between machines. Changeover on a repair line covers fixture swap, bit swap, recipe recall and first-article confirmation, from a few minutes to over an hour in total. Spread it over the batch and the dividing line shows up: for a batch of twenty units at ten screws each, forty minutes of changeover adds two minutes of fixed cost to every screw, longer than the removal itself. This is why many repair lines buy automation and cannot show a return — the machine is fine, the batch is too small and the changeover too slow for the amortisation to land. The productive direction is to compress changeover rather than takt: standardise fixture interfaces, bind recipes to product barcodes, and make first-article confirmation a machine self-check, which together typically halve changeover time.
Conclusion: whether to automate screw removal should be decided by the break-even point, not by the fact that the industry is automating. The arithmetic is direct: write cost per screw for the manual option and for the automated option as functions of batch size, and their intersection is the break-even batch. Manual cost grows linearly with low fixed cost; automated cost carries high fixed cost and low variable cost, so automation is more expensive in small batches and cheaper past the crossing. Three variables move that crossing. A yield advantage shifts it left sharply, because secondary damage repair costs far more than removal itself. A long changeover shifts it right, because fixed cost spreads over fewer pieces. Staffing difficulty and turnover belong in the decision too: repair roles carry a high skill threshold and a long training curve, and that hidden cost can be modelled as a higher effective labour rate. For repair businesses with a wide size spread, the value of a small screw removal equipment platform comes mainly from pushing secondary damage down, which happens to be the heaviest variable in the model.
Conclusion: a cost model only manages anything once it becomes daily metrics, and three matter most: removal time per screw, secondary damage rate, and changeover share of available time. Track removal time by model and screw size, since a group that rises abnormally usually signals a change in incoming condition or bit wear. Record secondary damage by cause, because stripping, head shear, bore cracking and harness tearing each need a different countermeasure. Changeover share reflects line flexibility, and a high share points to batch structure or fixture standardisation problems. All three can come straight from machine data, provided the machine logs torque curves, screw counts and program switch times rather than only powered hours. Bringing pre-removal assessment into the flow also makes attribution easier: once screw presence and head condition are recorded before the first drive, a later failure can be assigned to incoming condition or to process, and the images an automatic vision screw removal machine captures before breakaway become part of the cost evidence trail.
Conclusion: the most direct way to translate the model into a quotation structure is to band by screw size and incoming condition instead of quoting one price per model. The bands follow the cost drivers: size sets torque and bit life, incoming condition sets secondary damage probability, and the combination usually yields no more than six bands that a customer can follow. Unit pricing averages those bands away, so simple models subsidise complex ones and new units subsidise old ones, and the loss grows with volume. Banding has a useful side effect: customers start sorting incoming units by condition themselves, because mixed delivery becomes visibly expensive to them. For a line serving several brands, binding bands to machine recipes and covering the range with one M0.8-M2.0 screw removal solution keeps the quotation and the process parameters in step instead of running two separate realities.
Related Articles
/ RECOMMENDED NEWS